Imagine you’re a heroine in a horror film– the house is unusually quiet and something feels wrong. It’s at this point you can do one of two things: follow your gut and remove yourself from the situation or investigate further. Since you’re in a horror film, you’ve made the second choice, and it’s inevitably put you face to face with the monster. This is what builds suspense and horror in film after-all, right?
What if you had followed choice number one though– what if you’d followed your gut?
Don’t you feel lucky that your real life is not a horror film (I know I always am!)? It seems women are extra blessed and have strong guttural instincts. Whether or not we listen to them is another story, but over the years, I feel that I’ve gotten quite good at listening to mine.

via We Heart It
Following Your Gut…. When Meeting New People.
After moving to Bloomington, the Boy and I went shopping with a girl he’d met, as a costume party was coming up and she’d offered to show us the costume stores in town. I made lots of conversation with her, asking questions about her schooling and interests: the Boy had told me a lot about her and I thought she & I could make good friends. I kept getting this funny feeling when with her though– she wouldn’t look me directly in the eyes, acted sheepish or as though she’d been caught.
As she parted ways with us and the Boy and I walked down the street, I turned and asked him, “What’s going on between you two?” The Boy, in all naivete, proclaimed that nothing was. When he broke up with me a month later, she made a move on him that night.
This scenario sticks out in my head years later (and even though he & she are no longer on speaking terms, and the Boy & I are stronger than ever). It’s the first time I consciously remember feeling in my gut strong distrust for a person– and being right about it. During my time in Bloomington, I really learned to listen to my body’s instincts about people. To this day, they’ve only ever been wrong once– and that was when meeting the Boy.
When it comes to people, your spidey sense knows when there’s something wrong. Listen to it, follow it, believe in it. It doesn’t mean you have to be rude to people or avoid them when you’re getting bad vibes off of them…. it just means be cordial and distant whenever you come in contact with them.
Following Your Gut… When Shopping
It’s so easy to get caught up in the adrenaline of shopping with girlfriends (or in a frenzy as 12:00 pm hits and a Gilt sale starts). Sometimes I catch myself questioning my own instincts when it comes to potential purchases– because it may not be there in 20 minutes, because my girlfriends think it looks fabulous on me, or because I’m in the mood to shop. But like when you meet new people, sometimes you pull an item out of the box, put an item on, and…. you just don’t feel it.
Follow that feeling. Put it back in the box. Put it back on the hanger. Put it back on the shelf. Walk away from it. If you find yourself thinking about it later, than maybe your initial feelings weren’t right. Go back and try it on later, without 3rd party interference or salesgirls trying to make their commission. That 2nd viewing will tell you a lot more about your feelings.
Following Your Gut…. In the Workplace
It happens to all of us–we start that new job, and there is the coworker who rubs us the wrong way. Not because they listen to music loudly or hum on the other side of your cubicle wall. Not because they smell oddly, either. Rather, they rub us the wrong way because, like that person we’ve just met above.
Or we’ve just been given an assignment or task, and it doesn’t feel right to do it. I find this happens in non-profits a lot–I worked with a film festival that had horrible financial accountability; I worked with a performing arts company where they’d “bury” expenditures in accounts when they were out of money in another. You know what you’re being asked to do is wrong– but how do you stand up to your supervisor?
If you’re bold, you can say, “I’m not comfortable doing that…can you explain to me why we are doing it that way?” (or you can ask it of another coworker who you may feel more comfortable with). Or if you’re uncomfortable with a coworker, you CAN take it up to a supervisor, manager, or Human Resources director. Because one thing I’ve found out…. if someone or something is making you uncomfortable, chances are other people feel the same way. This is your JOB– and companies and the government set up certain guidelines and ethics for a reason– don’t be afraid to use that as an excuse. Following your gut at work can help you keep your job and earn the respect of your colleagues.
Following Your Gut… In Love
We’ve all been in those situations where it is easy to mix up our heart and our instinct. It was that time when your girlfriends finally stopped telling you to dump the dude, and they finally stopped saying you’re too good for him, because they’re were tired of fighting you on it. Or it’s that time they told you to stop picking up guys at that local dive bar where the music, men, and drinks were cheap and oh-so-good-but-oh-so-bad.
The truth is, in love, no one knows what’s real and true except you and your lover. There’s a time when YOU have to pull your heart aside and say, “Dearest Heart, I know you love him, but are we overlooking something?” That’s when you have to let that feeling in the pit of your stomach take over (perhaps with a bit of friendly advice by your friend, Rationale).
I’ve been in this one. I’ve been in this one for the past 4 years. I’ve made my girlfriends excited and frustrated countless times when I’ve regaled them with a story about what the Boy has done. There have been many times when my Heart has tried to trick me as my Gut and say, “You know, maybe we SHOULD finally give up.” But then my Gut says, “Hey hey hey! Stop doing MY job. You’re supposed to go fawn.” My gut and heart have fought for years on this one– but it seems that my gut feeling may be winning.
It’s hard to let go of our rational selves to listen to part of us that is undefinable and unexplainable. How do we rationalize, to ourselves and others?–I find that part often scares people more. But everyone has that instinctual feeling, and everyone has followed it before. Let go of your fear of explaining things, and listen to yourself more– I know that I have, and while I sometimes questions the decisions I’ve made as a result (giving up jobs in New York City, moving to be with a man), I’ll never give up the experiences that they gave me. Ultimately, following my gut kept me from confronting any monsters.












{ 30 comments… read them below or add one }
i really enjoyed this post! I’m far too rational a girl and I rarely have a gut feeling about anything (i wish i did), but I am pretty decisive and take decisions fairly quickly and then stick to them. I think it’s important to trust your own judgement and not be overly influenced by others – regardless of how you arrived at your decision, whether it’s instinct or by weighing up the evidence. I think you’re absolutely right that in love in particular noone *really* knows whats going on in people’s relationships other than those involved. The most important thing to remember is that your decisions make you who you are, so there’s no point in obsessing over what could have been.
.-= Franca´s last blog ..A guided tour of my newly tidy wardrobe and some tips on how to organise your own =-.
“I think it’s important to trust your own judgement and not be overly influenced by others – regardless of how you arrived at your decision, whether it’s instinct or by weighing up the evidence.”
I absolutely agree, Franca! I think that our rationale and logical decision making is JUST as important as following our gut–and it’s equally important to be confident in both those methods.
“The most important thing to remember is that your decisions make you who you are, so there’s no point in obsessing over what could have been.”
Beautifully said!
This is a great post! I think I need to follow my gut more often.
.-= Leia´s last blog ..Haircut =-.
I love this! It’s so true, that when we follow our instincts things just work better! I think it takes practice though and the more we follow our instincts and listen to them the more in tune they become. Great post!
.-= Fajr | Stylish Thought´s last blog ..Style Sample Magazine—it’s Finally Here! =-.
You’re definitely right– practice makes perfect, like in any aspect of our life. I find that mine, the more I listen to it, the better off I am.
You’re post today reminds me of this line from the film High Fidelity…
“Should I bolt every time I get that feeling in my gut when I meet someone new? Well, I’ve been listening to my gut since I was 14 years old, and frankly speaking, I’ve come to the conclusion that my guts have shit for brains.”
I ALWAYS follow my gut when it comes to people. Last time I met someone who rubbed me the wrong way (even aside from his bad manners & etc.), he turned out to be a child molester, no shit!
I’m not quite so good when it comes to clothing items though, I am notorious for waffling in stores while my shopping partner (most often Matt), stands and sighs impatiently.
.-= Michelle´s last blog ..Marvelous Monday! =-.
Oh man! That’s a great case of listening to your instincts, Michelle.
For what it’s worth, I bet that shopping bit we ALL have the most problems with D:
Excellent point about listening to your gut feelings.
Sometimes it is hard to sort out which is which as you try to be rational. But you can only hope that everything will turn out ok when you do what you think is right I suppose!
.-= Retro Chick´s last blog ..My New Mulberry Dress & a Charity Reminder =-.
Wonderful post, Ashe. You have to (x3) listen to your instincts. Ignoring mine got me into worlds of trouble.
.-= Alicia´s last blog ..…011810… =-.
Following my gut about someone last year would have saved me a lot of drama, that’s for sure.
.-= WendyB´s last blog ..The Golden Globes, Diane Kruger and Listerine =-.
My gut instincts about people and situations are always really accurate, and I’m just starting to learn to follow them. I liked what you said about not being rude to people you have a bad feeling about, only acting “cordial and distant.” That’s such a great way to put it and really is the best way to handle a lot of those situations to avoid unnecessary drama.
.-= Kylie´s last blog ..Twitter: Serious Business =-.
It really is! Said boyfriend-stealing-girl? I managed to be civil with her at parties and events, and even be nice and occasionally complimentary. Does it mean I’d trust an ounce of her? No chance in hell. But it sure did make social gatherings more enjoyable.
Excellent post, and a great reminder. If I’d have followed my gut with my ex, I’d have sent him packing after the second date and saved myself much grief. Sometimes it can be tough to hear what your gut has to say; your heart’s just so much louder sometimes — plus it’s closer to your ears. ;-)
.-= Audi´s last blog ..Equestrian Romantic =-.
Oh sweet Audi, you are SO right about your heart being louder and closer… sometimes its like that nosey always butting in neighbor… ;)
Such a thought-provoking post! I must say, I find love to be the most difficult of these situations. It’s tough when your head and your gut tell you someone’s not right for you — but your heart won’t accept it. I made a decision years ago that, every once in a while, I still wonder about. I ended up following my gut and my head. I think I made the right decision.
Good luck to you Ashe~
XO Piper
.-= DailyDivaDish´s last blog ..Janis Joplin =-.
Great post! It takes a while to learn to trust our instincts and the first step is to know ourselves well. I usually trust my instincts but I also try to keep a distance from myself – after all, sometimes we can be prejudiced. My rule is to give everything a second though but most of the time I go for the first option.
Second thoughts are always good– we CAN be prejudiced. God knows that if I had not gone with that second chance, the Boy and I wouldn’t be where we are today. And I can’t imagine my life without him. Knowing ourselves is a HUGE part of it, and I’m glad you pointed that out!
Amazing! Subject matter AND the writing, going to read again.
Great advice!!
Great advice. I tend to actually not have very good guts when it comes to people, but when it comes to shopping, my guts are almost always on target if I listen to them.
I just have a hard time actually LISTENING to my guts when it comes to shopping! Sometimes that compulsion overwhelms me…
I love this post! I used to be great at following my instincs, but then I started having to remind myself to. It is the best way to stay true to yourself.
This is great, and real & useful advice. Thank you for writing! I will share this link on my blog. :)
Awe Ashe,
I love this post! What a great idea – very original – brava Ashe!
Excellent point, something we girls need to remind ourselves of often. Reading and rereading Women Who Run with the Wolves a couple of years ago was good training and reinforcement on honing one’s instincts – it saved my life, gave me permission to change careers, and got me ready to meet my now-husband… highly recommended.
Great blog post!
.-= Allie´s last blog ..Oh, for cryin’ out loud… =-.
Allie, I’m going to have to check out “Women Who Run With Wolves”– I haven’t heard of it, but it sounds like a great read. The impact it has had on you sounds amazing!
This post speaks to me on so many levels. I am loving the fact that you covered not just fashion; but following your gut in multiple situations!! :)
.-= Cafe Fashionista´s last blog ..Why Don’t You…? =-.
Nice article, Ashe! Reading it reminded me of a great book – How We Decide by John Lehrer. Basically, the book says that many decisions are best made on gut instinct because our emotional brain is faster and usually smarter than our logical brain. It outlines why and provides in-depth technical details. An interesting read.
.-= Little Miss Makeup´s last blog ..Are you tired of your foundation wearing off part way through the day? =-.
Whoops, that should have been Jonah Lehrer, not John Lehrer. Sorry, silly me!
.-= Little Miss Makeup´s last blog ..Are you tired of your foundation wearing off part way through the day? =-.
{ 13 trackbacks }