I may not be healthy, but neither is she.

I may not be healthy, but neither is she.

From questions of “Are you pregnant?” (no, I’m not) to “Are you REALLY going to eat that?” (why yes, yes I am), it’s no fun being fat. And sometimes it’s hard to love fashion, when “fashion is not for fatties.”

Since my childhood, weight has always been a constant struggle; from being a size 10 to upwards of an 18/20, vanity sizing has been both my friend and my foe. I know that I will never be waif thin or long and lean, and at the very least, I want to feel healthy & sexy in my body. Clothing companies aren’t going to make that easy on me, no matter what my size, so why should I?

Living in the Mid-West, particularly in a Big Ten College Town, leads to a lot of unhealthy eating (and a lot of watching the runners jog on by). Between the hurricane, a break-up, losing my regular workout routine, and an intense graduate school program, I’d be lying if I said I didn’t pack on the pounds.

And worse than packing on the pounds? Feeling my physical and mental health deteriorate through it all.

To try and rectify the past, and build up a healthier future, I’ve flirted with a Diet. But I think Dieting is a damned dirty word. It encourages us to think about our bodies in quantitative terms (the number of our weight, our BMI, the size of our pants) rather than qualitatively (how we feel, how we look, what our overall health is).

So I’ve been trying to think about my “Diet,” not so much as a Diet, but a Resolution for a Healthier Body.

The Faux Beau and I have been flirting with the South Beach Diet; during the Summer, we successfully managed to complete Phase I and move in to Phase 2. Then an onslaught of trips, VERY limited funds, and a shortened schedule made us slip up big time!

One of the most appealing aspects of the South Beach Diet is that it really isn’t so much of a diet at all. Rather, it seems to be a guide to healthy eating (specially for decreasing heart disease and cholestorol); it comes in many forms, and is similar to the Sonoma Diet. It encourages you to eat healthy fats and carbs, to decrease the processed foods in your diet, to break your addiction to artifical sugars and sweeteners. In short, it fills your body up with healthy proteins and fats, fiber, and natural sugars, while breaking your body’s dependency on foods with high glycemic indexes.

Many of the more satisfying aspects of the “Diet” include: eating until you fill full; allowing you to eat at restaurants (and offering suggestions of best options!); and a no-guilt policy towards days that you break it and holidays.

When it comes to food, I find that listening to our bodies is the most important thing we can do. When I do this, I am at a smaller size, yes, but I also have more energy and stamina.  Instead of listening to the small voice in my head reminding me how good that double cheeseburger would be, or how the cheesey soup sounds better than the veggie filled one, I should listen to the other parts of my body too– my stomach, intestines, heart, and lungs. If my heart starts pounding at the sight of that cheeseburger, maybe I should pass it up in favor of a salad that won’t push my cholesterol up…

Does anyone else feel the pains and struggles of weight management?  How do you cope with it?  Are you restrictive of your diet at all?  Do you find successes in “Diets,” whether its as simple as being a vegetarian or as complex as counting points?

Share/Save/Bookmark

Related posts:

  1. TiLT! [October 23th!] An accomplishment– actually getting this list up on a...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.


Subscribe to comments Comment | Trackback |
Post Tags:

Browse Timeline


Comments ( 25 )

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

ShopDiary » Blog Archive » Links à la Mode: IFB Weekly Roundup added these pithy words on Nov 27 08 at 11:59 am

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Links a La Mode: The Independent Fashion Bloggers Roundup! « added these pithy words on Nov 27 08 at 1:21 pm

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Fashion Links à la Mode: November 27th 2008 | Petite Bourgeoisie: Digital Fashion added these pithy words on Nov 27 08 at 3:24 pm

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Read A Blog Save The World: November 28th | Your Style Star added these pithy words on Nov 27 08 at 5:57 pm

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Links à la Mode « Some Like It Fashion added these pithy words on Nov 28 08 at 6:18 am

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Links à la Mode : The Indpendent Fashion Blogger | THE COVETED added these pithy words on Nov 28 08 at 7:39 am

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Clutch 22 | Fashion & Shopping Insider added these pithy words on Nov 29 08 at 9:06 am

[...] Why Dieting is a Dirty Word | dramatis personae [...]

Quickest Way to Lose Weight | health-web-guide added these pithy words on Nov 29 08 at 11:58 am

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Links à la Mode | 39thandbroadway.com added these pithy words on Nov 30 08 at 2:06 pm

[...] dramatis personae - Why Dieting is a Dirty Word [...]

Links a la Mode : The Bare Skinny added these pithy words on Nov 30 08 at 8:25 pm

My weight has fluctuated over the years. I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism kind of late but I don’t that is the cause of all of my weight issues. I tried the South Beach & Atkins diets and felt horrible. I did the “six week body makeover” which actually worked pretty well. It was common sense (basically eating whole foods and not a lot of carbs excepty whole ones like potatoes and rice) but I was also running then. That was the thinnest I had been as an adult.

My biggest issue right now is working in exercise. I am sitting down almost all day and somewhat addicted to the computer, between work and blogging and all the other social media stuff. I’ve also had reoccuring stomach issues in the past.

As you know from talking with me on Twitter, we switched to a vegetarian way of life. And I have to saw it has been an amazingly good and easy switch. More so than I could have ever anticipated. We never really ate fast food or drank soda or anything, but even so, I’m losing weight gradually.

Not only that, I feel great physically and emotionally. It’s hard to explain and unexpected but I feel more peaceful. And weirdly, after having these weird emotions all my life, I’m having fewer emotionally-charged issues with food. No guilt or stress. I just eat when I’m hungry.

I’m not saying it’s perfect and I’m not saying it’s magical but in the course of my entire life and all the things I’ve tried and done, this has been the easiest change and the most holistically life-changing in a good way.

Luv
Poochie

Princess Poochie added these pithy words on Nov 23 08 at 1:35 pm

While I’m fairly lucky with my weight — fortunate genes counteract my Cadbury Dairy Milk consumption — I definitely have a problem with emotional/bored eating. When I force myself to pay attention to my appetite, I can recognize when I’m not hungry. Of course, sometimes I’m so bored that I eat anyway. Sigh.

WendyB added these pithy words on Nov 23 08 at 2:24 pm

I have been steadily losing weight over the past few years. I’ve gone from a size 14 to a size 10 very gradually, and that is due to listening to my bodies needs, as you said.
I find that knowing and paying attention to calories assist me in this, as I can eat whatever I like and make sacrifices if I need to. For example, If I fall into the grasp of the cheeseburger, I know that I should have vegetable soup for my tea. I have been eating like this for so long, it is second nature, and now I seem to have plateaued on a healthy weight. I don’t really think too much about food any more, it’s purely just one of those good things in life.

Melanie added these pithy words on Nov 23 08 at 3:33 pm

I’ve fought with weight gain over the last few years, and girl, I hear you–it sucks to be passionate about fashion but deemed too large to wear it yourself. I’m about a size large or 10-12 and I’m too big for nearly everything I want to wear…and that’s just depressing. Between my chronic physical pain and the constant emotional blows doled out by clothes shopping, there are days wherein I just want to upload my brain to an iPod and be done with my useless carcass.

But…the one thing that’s both helped me level with my size and make better choices about what I put into my system is learning to love my kitchen. I’ve become a foodie this year and I find that I eat less when the food I have in my cupboards is GOOD. I have nearly no processed foodlike substances in my house. Forcing myself to cook nearly every night has turned eating into a DIY endeavor, and I feel in control and empowered, not to mention I’m saving money and being kinder to our planet. I’ve also found that cooking and eating with friends keeps me from pigging out–I spend more time talking, laughing, and scrambling around the kitchen than stuffing my face.

So yeah; there’s that. And I miss you. Maybe we can get together and cook when I come home?

Libby Bulloff added these pithy words on Nov 23 08 at 6:43 pm

I saw that ad too, and I actually pointed it out to my fiance, saying “That is just UNHEALTHY looking. That’s either a 12 year old girl, an anorexic woman, or someone Photoshopped all to hell.”

I don’t have a whole lot of experienc with dieting - I’ve been a vegetarian since sixth grade (eight or nine years now) but it was always for ethical reasons and I have no trouble with it. I was actually a vegan for six months and THAT was unhealthy for me. It is totally possible to do it and be healthy, but I live in a tiny midwestern town where there are few resources and I already have a fast metabolism, so I dropped down to 95 pounds. I’m 5′1″-5′2″, so that’s not the death sentence it’d be for a lot of people, but it was still unhealthy. I’ve put on 20 or so pounds in the last year, mostly “filling out” and I’m perfectly ok with it…wish my thighs were a little smaller but eh. I don’t really feel any need to diet because I feel fine and I hate most aspects of the dieting industry, it’s tied in to all kinds of icky feelings for me. I think for the most part our culture’s obsession with dieting is REALLY unhealthy, to say the least. I do keep meaning to start doing yoga and/or pilates again but just have a hard time making time for it and getting around to doing it. I’m also hypoglycemic, which means I try to watch what I eat anyways, so adding calorie-counting into it would be WAY too much for my lazy-ass self!

Michelle added these pithy words on Nov 23 08 at 7:06 pm

I feel for ya!

Thanks to some health problems I’ve had, my weight has also yo-yo’d quite a bit over the years. Before, I could eat whatever I wanted and stay thin. Then things happened and I went up 50 pounds, then down 30, and then back up 30, with plenty more minor fluctuations in between. Not fun — and not cheap, since I’ve had to buy a lot of clothes along the way. At least completely replacing my wardrobe several times has given me plenty of experience with developing a figure flattering style. Ha.

I’ve never had much luck with “diets”, but I have lost the weight before just by eating healthier and eating less (that is, when I haven’t also been fighting meds that pack on the pounds — in which case nothing works). It’s a painfully slow process, but it generally works.

Unfortunately, this time around I’m now having problems with insulin resistance. Even though I was eating very low-cal, I was still gaining weight because I was eating things like brown rice and potatoes daily. I was also completely exhausted. Now I know better and have adjusted my diet to include fewer high GI foods and more low GI foods. So far, it does look like things are turning around — and none too soon since I really need my winter wardrobe to fit better. I’m not expecting an overnight miracle, though. I definitely don’t want to be as thin as that poor gal in the ad — just a healthy, stable weight.

Anyhow, good luck!

Meg added these pithy words on Nov 24 08 at 12:10 am

I know fashion is not kind to us bigger girls, but you always seem to look fabulous. I’ve sort of given up on the day to day fashion and always wear jeans to work.

I found out I’m lactose intolerant last week and I lost five pounds the first week off dairy. I’ve been vegetarian for about six years though and have been around the same weight since before I went veggie.

If you’re still having tummy issues, you may want to try an elimination diet (or seeing a doctor/nutritionist/naturopath) to find out if there are certain foods causing problems. Cutting down on or giving up foods that cause you to feel sick might naturally cause you to lose weight, whether you cut calories or not. I’ve read that we actually crave the things that our bodies can’t digest, like lactose intolerant people crave dairy (even if they don’t know they’re intolerant). Since giving up dairy, I feel more free, like food isn’t something that’s there to cheer me up when I’m sad or bored, but I feel like I have to make myself eat a few meals a day. I still enjoy food, but it doesn’t feel like as major a part of my life as it used to. I hope this keeps up.

Lara added these pithy words on Nov 24 08 at 2:24 am

Dave’s been trying to change his diet lately, and has started bicycling more, both for transportation & exercise. I can already see some improvement, which is good cause it was at the point where it wasn’t just him being whiny, but it really was noticeable that he’d put on some weight. (Not to mention that he couldn’t fit into any of his old clothes anymore.) He’s been trying to concentrate on eating a lot of whole foods, raw foods as much as possible. It helps that salads are like his favorite meal anyway, but he’s also been trying to snack on stuff like an avocado or an apple rather than chips or crackers. I think that’s a big part of it for anyone… eat as much as you want/until you’re not hungry, just fill your body with stuff it needs, not highly processed crap. I’m trying to become better about it too, but I need to find more fruits and veggies that I really LOVE, not just ones I can sort of tolerate. At least I like raw broccoli as a snack? It’s still smothered in ranch dressing, but I figure that’s a start?

Mallory @ MissMalaprop added these pithy words on Nov 24 08 at 9:05 am

I’ve always been a lil chubbalub, except during my unhealthy rave days of 2000. I am a big glutton and love to indulge myself in all facets of life but in reality moderation IS the key. I am on weight watchers because I’m so familiar with the program (trying it ten fucking times) it has been working for me so far. Really though, it’s all up to the person. If you aren’t ready to change your lifestyle you will gain back the weight. LETS HOPE I CAN DO IT!

Marie added these pithy words on Nov 24 08 at 1:11 pm

You are all so fantastic! I am so glad to have so many varying, thoughtful, and amazing responses…

@Princess Poochie - You & I both share two things– trying to find time to work out and recurring stomach ailments! I think a good first step for me (similarly to you) is cutting out fast food + soda. Soda isn’t normally an issue for me, but during the winter I want to drink anything BUT water. I admire how you & the hubby have had such an easy transition to vegetarianism and veganism…

@WendyB - Wendy, I think you and I would be great emotional eater buddies. Which could be a bad thing, but perhaps there’s a way to make it healthy…

@Melanie - Congratulations– finding that healthy plateau where you feel good and can stop thinking about food is amazing (I do remember that one well!).

@Libby Bulloff - I have *GOT* to get better about cooking in the kitchen… your posts definitely inspire me to do that! And I miss you, and lets DEFINITELY do foodie and craftie when you come home.

@Michelle - I’m so glad to know that I’m not the only one who saw that ad and had to point it out! She looks so unhealthy… sad doesn’t even describe how it makes me feel. Exercise is definitely hard to work in to a life routine… I have such a hard time finding time now!

@Meg - The expense and changing wardrobe kills me! I want my Trashy Diva dresses back, damn it. I’m with you on the GI issue– I’m trying to be better and include lots of low GI foods in my diet, or know at least why I’m eating some of the high GI ones (like potatoes– still filled with TONS of nutrients. I crave them like crazy when my potassium is low).

@Lara - I’d give up on day-to-day and wear jeans if I could get away with it! I honestly wonder if a lot of my tummy problems, especially as a child, had to do with lack of fiber in my diet. My parents didn’t exactly raise me on a whole grain lots of veggies diet, so it’d make sense that’s why I don’t digest foods well. I wish a nutritionist were covered by our insurance, because it’d be nice to go just to be sure!

@Mallory @ MissMalaprop - You need the ranch dressing, Pooks. You’re getting too skinny! (I know I sound like your dad now, but whateva, it’s true.)

@Marie - Good luck, my love! I hear lots of great things about Weight Watchers, and you’re so right about moderation– something I definitely need to work on!

admin added these pithy words on Nov 24 08 at 3:55 pm

Ashe, do you drink a lot of tea? I love the stuff. Hot tea doesn’t really do it for me most of the time, but a glass of cold tea out of the fridge is so refreshing. I usually drink it unsweetened (a crime here in the South so don’t tell anyone!), but it’s also really good with stevia.

Meg added these pithy words on Nov 24 08 at 7:37 pm

@Meg - I wouldn’t say a lot, but I definitely love tea! I cut out a lot of my coffee consumption this year and switched to tea as my “caffeine” of choice (with occasional decaf coffee). Hot & cold, sweet or not, I love them all– though my consumption definitely increases in the winter time!

I have some Agave nectar, and I bet that would be delish in place of honey!

admin added these pithy words on Nov 24 08 at 8:16 pm

hi

Sorry to bother you- I was left off of many posts for this weeks IFB Posts for Thanksgiving Thursday- would you mind adding me to yours when you do yours? Under Shop Maven - Shopping and Info - Thanks.

Shopping and Info added these pithy words on Nov 28 08 at 8:49 pm

Honestly, I am terrible sometimes - like a naughty child! I flit from being ridiculously saint-like with my diet one moment, to appallingly bad the next - it is insane! I’m fortunate that I tend to lose weight fairly quickly, however I also GAIN weight quickly, too - so I definitely need to monitor what I eat. Recently, I made a pact to stop obsessing over food labels, packaging and magazine articles, and instead concentrate on the nutritional value of my food - I try now to think of my body as a car, and that in order for it to go the distance, I need to fuel it properly! Sure, I still slip up sometimes, but thinking this way is a much more enjoyable approach to eating, and it makes me positively question what I put in my mouth, rather than thinking ”I shouldn’t eat this cheeseburger because I don’t want my thighs to explode!”

Great post :) xx

x Miss Corrine x added these pithy words on Dec 02 08 at 2:35 pm

Oh yeah, reading this made me think of something I’d read before: this HCG diet thing. Have you heard of it? It involves injecting/ingesting (the way I understand it) pregnancy hormones and only eating 500 calories a day. Sounds CRAZY to me!

Michelle added these pithy words on Dec 02 08 at 6:06 pm

Add a Comment


XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>